Skip to main content

Final Cut Pro X Poor Quality Pixelation on Render and Export to H.264 MP4

I encountered a frustrating issue this morning while attempting to deliver a finished product to the client.

Pixelation occurred on different parts of the exported video.

They appear during some transitions, including on the first frame of straight cuts.

They occur randomly at different transitions on every export.

Troubleshoot - What did I do to solve the problem?

Is it the Compressor custom H.264 settings? No.  Tweaked settings to higher quality.

Is it the MacBook Pro GPU issue? No.  Turned GPU off.

Is it the Render Format setting? Probably.  

Turned off timeline background rendering and deleted generated event files.  Export still pixelate.

Turned on timeline background rendering and pixelation observed occurring in timeline playback. 

Changed Project Render Format from “Apple ProRes 422” to “Apple ProRes 422 HQ”.  Pixelation still occur in timeline playback.
Background Render on

Background Render off

Deleted Generated Event Files.  Background Rendered timeline at Apple ProRes 422 HQ.  No more pixelation in timeline playback.

Exported to MP4 H.264 1080 25p 7Mbps.  NO MORE RANDOM PIXELATION!

Have I discovered the solution?  NOOOOOO!

Using the same procedure above on the second project, pixelation occurred again in the timeline playback.

Deleted Generated Event Files.  Background Rendered timeline at Apple ProRes 422 HQ.  NO MORE pixelation in timeline playback.

(The common thing I did was… during the background render, I stayed in FCPx without multi-tasking to another app.)

Exported to MP4 H.264 1080 25p 7Mbps.  NO MORE RANDOM PIXELATION! (I multi-tasked to this blog while exporting.)

Conclusion - What can be done better next time?

For high quality H.264 MP4 export on Final Cut Pro X v10.1.3:

  1. Set Render Format to Apple ProRes 422 HQ.
  2. Turn on Background Render.
  3. Delete generated event files before export.
  4. Let the background render happen.
  5. DO NOT LEAVE FCPx during background render (do not multi-task to other apps).
  6. Playback the timeline to check quality after background render.
  7. Export if all is good.
Update 16 sep 2014: The above method did not work subsequently.  Annoying pixelation still appear randomly and different transition point.

So here are the steps that worked today:

  1. Turned off MacBook Pro GPU.
  2. Turned off Background Render. 
  3. Delete generated library files.
  4. Delete generated event files.
  5. Export.
I will update this post if it does not work again.

Update 19 Sep 2014: This works too.
  1. Leave MacBook Pro GPU on (faster encoding).
  2. Leave Background Render off. 
  3. Delete generated library files.
  4. Delete generated event files.
  5. Export.


 Adrian Lee
1-day Video Editing Course with Final Cut Pro X – Singapore
http://videolane.com/courses/final-cut-pro/





Comments

  1. Adrian Lee3:49 pm

    Updated a new note at the end of the post.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Macbook Air M1 Case

I bought a transparent case for my MacBook Air M1 . It came with a free screen protector, a keyboard cover, and some rubber plugs to cover the ports. Check it out! https://youtu.be/d-wALSd3nn8 I didn't expect the rubber plugs. It was a nice surprise. The case fits snuggly, with access to all the ports. The keyboard cover is almost invisible to the eye. I have no intention to use the screen protector. Why? I need to see the true color of the display for my YouTube videos. ~ Adrian Lee  @Adrian Video Image  The video was recorded on iPhone 12 Pro Max with Filmic Pro app in 4K 60fps and edited with Capcut.
Post a Comment
Read more

Sony Vegas Pro 8 Tutorial - Multicamera Editing

Sony Vegas Pro 8 makes it easier to edit videos from different cameras right from the timeline. You can capture and edit video for a single scene from 2 or more cameras or for a single scene shot a few times with one camera. Here is a tutorial of a Multicamera Edit of a drama I shot. The drama was acted out four times to the public and being a non-profit organization, the client have budget only for one videographer. For each of the 4 acts, the camcorder (Sony HDR-FX7 High Definition Camcorder) was placed at 4 different positions and shot in various angles. Multicamera edit is accomplished in only 8 steps with the Sony Vegas Pro 8. Step #1: Capture Multicamera Video Clips Use the normal Sony Vegas Video Capture function to capture recordings from each camera. Give each capture filename a unique name. Enable scene detection before capturing so that each segment is captured as a separate clip. Step #2 : Layout Video Clips on Timeline Drag and drop video clips over each other on the...
27 comments
Read more

FCPX - The storage device "Macintosh HD" is almost full

The message "The storage device Macintosh HD is almost full" appeared when I was editing a video with Final Cut Pro X on my new Apple Macbook Air M1.   Final Cut Pro Taking up Too Much Space  My Macbook Air M1 had only 256GB of storage onboard. My raw footage was only about 9GB. The biggest file was the FCPX project files itself at about 140GB! How did 9GB become 140GB? There is not enough disk space for my Final Cut Pro. Why Is Final Cut Pro Taking up So Much Storage Final Cut Pro renders files in high-quality media so that we can playback our edits smoothly direct from the timeline.  It creates multiple HUGE high-quality files of our footage in the background.   It is a good thing, so as to maintain high-quality final edited video, BUT not a good thing for a laptop with only 256GB. How to Clear Disk Space on Final Cut Pro The question is how to delete the rendered files in FCPX? 1. Select the library in FCPX...  2. Go to Files > Delete Generated L...
Post a Comment
Read more